Supreme Court Decisions 2021-Present

Supreme Court Decisions 2021

Reinstatement Petition of Kevin Duffy, Supreme Court No. 17-1093, 1/8/21

Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Dennis R. Bailey, 21-0070 (2/1/21)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Anthony J. Zappin, 18-0250 (2/16/21)

Reinstatement Petition of Jennifer M. Greene, No. 20-0304 (WV 3/11/21)

Reinstatement Petition of David A. Kirkpatrick No. 21-0068 (WV 4/15/21)

Reinstatement Petition of David A. Kirkpatrick No. 21-0068 (WV 4/15/21)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. William M. Lester, Jr., Supreme Court No. 21-0145 (April 15, 2021)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Daniel S. Corey, Supreme Court NO. 20-0258 (April 15, 2021)

Resignation Petition of William P. Hagenbuch, Jr., Supreme Court NO. 18-0190 ( April 15, 2021)

Resignation Petition of Gabriel Kallen, Supreme Court NO. 20-1001

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Jonathan D. Fittro, No. 20-0542 (WV 4/15/21)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. David A. Mohler, No. 20-0260 (WV 4/15/21)

Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. John K. Chase, IV, Esquire, Supreme Court No. 21-0344, 5/13/21

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Harry W. Moore, Jr., No. 20-0110 (WV 5/13/2021)

Petition for Reinstatement of Keith L. Wheaton, Supreme Court No. 18-0836, (WV 6/14/21)

Resignation Petition of Adam Goebel, Supreme Court No. 20-0944, 6/14/21

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Sebastian M. Joy, No. 21-0177 (7/28/21)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Marc A. Moore, Supreme Court No. 21-0777, September 30, 2021

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Mark D. Panepinto, No. 20-0905 (10/07/21)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Jonathan R. Seabolt, No. 20-0868 (WV 10/7/21)

Reinstatement Petition of Travis C. Sayre, Supreme Court NO. 20-0414, 10/7/21

Resignation Petition of Robert Farley, Supreme Court No. 21-0092, 10/7/21

Resignation Petition of Ruben Toft Sindahl, Supreme Court No. 21-0089, 10/7/21

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Judith McCullough 21-0882 (11/4/21)

Reinstatement Petition of David D. Perry, Supreme Court No. 19-1180, November 10, 2021

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Joshua C. Cain, No. 20-0252 (12/1/21)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Justin J. Marcum, No. 20-0133 (WV Opinion 11/5/21)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Justin J. Marcum, No. 20-0133 (WV Mandate 12/7/21)

Supreme Court Decisions 2022

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Thomas J. Drake, No. 21-0292 (1/6/22)

Resignation Petition of Ryan Rummage, Supreme Court No. 21-0636, January 27, 2022

Resignation Petition of Karen Callahan, Supreme Court No. 0483, January 27, 2022

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Kirk H. Bottner – Supreme Court No. 21-0178, February 23, 2022

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. David E. Furrer, No. 20-1026 (WV 2/23/2022)

Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Marc A. Moore, No. 22-0138 (WV 2/23/22)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Marc A. Moore, No. 21-0840 (WV 2/28/22)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Jeffery A. Davis, 20-0871, March 14, 2022

Petition for Voluntary Resignation of Randall Appleton, Supreme Court No. 22-0026, 3/24/22

Reinstatement Petition of James B. Atkins, No. 21-0336 (WV 4/7/22)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Timothy P. Rosinsky, No. 21-0641 (WV 4/7/22)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Brian K. Carr, Supreme Court No. 22-0193, April 7, 2022

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Scott E. Elswick, Supreme Court No. 22-0343, May 5, 2022

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Leah Perry Macia, Supreme Court No. 20-0908, May 11, 2022

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Patrick L. Cottrell, Supreme Court No. 22-0455, 6/22/22

Resignation Petition of Deborah Herndon, Supreme Court No. 22-0224, 7/1/22

Resignation Petition of Stephen J. Rodolf, Supreme Court No. 22-0249, 7/1/22

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Holly Wolfe Hinerman 21-0164 (9-20-22)

Petition for Voluntary Resignation of Meghan Cloud, No. 22-0509, November 17, 2022

Petition for Voluntary Resignation of Joan Hill, No. 22-655, November 17, 2022

Petition for Voluntary Resignation of Joyce Nailing, No. 22-648, November 17, 2022

Reinstatement Petition of Justin J. Marcum, Supreme Court No. 22-0442, December 2, 2022

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. David R. Tyson & Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. David R. Tyson, Nos. 20-1027 & 22-0342 (WV Opinion 11/3/22)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. David R. Tyson & Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. David R. Tyson, Nos. 20-1027 & 22-0342 (WV Mandate 12/6/22)

Supreme Court Decisions 2023

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Dennis J. Willett, No. 21-1032 (WV 1/18/2023)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Gregory H. Schillace, Supreme Court No. 20-0233, February 17, 2023 (Opinion and Mandate)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. David W. Hummel, Jr., Supreme Court No. 23-92, March 23, 2023.

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Michael T. Hogan, Supreme Court No. 22-747, January 17, 2023

Voluntary Resignation Petition of Marcy L. Tenaglia, Supreme Court No. 22-846, January 27, 2023

Petition for Voluntary Resignation of James P. McGibbon, Supreme Court No. 23-51, March 23, 2023

Reinstatement Petition of Kirk H. Bottner, No. 22-656 (WV 3/30/23)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Stephen A. Wickland, Supreme Court No. 23-122, March 23, 2023

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v . Phillip R. Amick, Supreme Court No. 23-50, April 3, 2023

Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Phillip R. Amick, Supreme Court No. 22-569, April 3, 2023

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Amanda B. Godwin, Sup. Ct. No. 22-813 (4/21/23)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Amanda B. Godwin¸ Sup. Ct. No. 23-98 (4/21/23)

LDB v. John B. Morgan, Supreme Court No. 22-571 (4/21/23)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Andrew Courtenay Craig, No. 22-614 (WV 4/21/23)

Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. James J. Palmer, III, No. 23-110 (WV 4/21/23)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. James J. Palmer, III, No. 22-0490 (WV 4/21/23)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Keith L. Wheaton 23-187 (5/11/23)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Robert E. Glenn, Supreme Court No. 23-218, May 12, 2023

LDB v. Matthew E. DeVore, Supreme Court No. 22-599 (WV 5/12/2023)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Jeffery A. Davis 22-657 (5/12/23)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Phillip S. Isner 22-570 (6/12/23)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Kenneth Brian Adkins, Supreme Court No. 23-295 (6/9/23)

Resignation Petition of Matthew P. Moriarty, Supreme Court No. 23-200, July 5, 2023

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. James C. Griesacker, Supreme Court No. 22-828, 9/12/23

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. M. Paul Marteney, Supreme Court No. 22-817 (WV 9/12/2023)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Keith Wheaton, Supreme Court No. 23-187, 9/8/23

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Holly Wolfe Hinerman 22-804 (10/20/23)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Wells H. Dillon, Supreme Court No. 23-845, 10/20/23

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. James M. Pierson, Supreme Court No. 21-0590 (WV Opinion 11/8/23)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. James M. Pierson, Supreme Court No. 21-0590 (WV Mandate 12/11/23)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Thomas F. Basile, No. 23-590, October 20, 2023

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. James W. Keenan, No. 22-0510, November 15, 2023

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. J. Steven Hunter, No. 22-0123, November 21, 2023

Supreme Court Decisions 2024

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Xavier W. Staggs, Supreme Court No. 23-685 1/22/24

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. J. Michael Anderson, Supreme Court No. 23-730 1/22/24

Reinstatement of Mark A. Glover – WVSC No. 22-555 – ODC Case ID No. 22-05-264

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Michael J. Novotny, Supreme Court No. 23-626, April 15, 2024

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Phillip B. Ball, Supreme Court No. 22-582, April 15, 2024

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Phillip B. Ball, Supreme Court No. 23-706, April 15, 2024

Petition for Voluntary Resignation from the West Virginia State Bar of Jeffry H. Hall, Supreme Court No. 23-453, April 15, 2024

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Joshua Mingo Winters, Supreme Court No. 22-925 (WV 4/15/2024)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Jeffery A. Davis, Sr. 22-916 (4/26/2024)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Jeffery A. Davis, Sr. 22-916 (4/26/2024)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Carl P. Bryant, Supreme Court No. 24-108 (4/29/2024)

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. James W Keenan, Supreme Court No. 23-619 (WV 5/09/2024)

State of West Virginia Ex Rel. The Honorable Timothy L. Sweeney, Judge of the Circuit Court of Pleasants County v. William Mundy, et al., Supreme Court No. 23-342 (WV 6/07/2024)

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. M. Paul Marteney, Supreme Court No. 23-709, June 13, 2024


Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Patrick Doheny, Supreme Court No. 18-0363, 7/9/24

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Christopher S. Moorehead, a deceased member of the West Virginia State Bar, Supreme Court No. 24-378, July 25, 2024

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Thomas Jason Drake, Supreme Court No. 24-219, July 31, 2024

Petition for Voluntary Resignation from the West Virginia State Bar of Kaylie S. Tucker, Supreme Court No. 23-487, August 16, 2024

Petition for Voluntary Resignation from the West Virginia State Bar of Taylor A. Gillespie, Supreme Court No. 23-499, August 16, 2024

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Keith L. Wheaton, Supreme Court No. 24-130, August 27, 2024

Petition for Reinstatement of Keith L. Wheaton, Supreme Court No. 23-605, August 27, 2024

Petition for Voluntary Resignation from the West Virginia State Bar of John P. Maier, Supreme Court No. 24-111, September 27, 2024

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Colin M. Cline, Supreme Court No. 22-922, October 18, 2024

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Brett N. Mayes, Supreme Court No. 24-159, October 18, 2024

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. J. Mingo Winters, Supreme Court No. 24-211, October 18, 2024

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. J. Mingo Winters, Supreme Court No. 23-724, October 18, 2024


Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. David D. Perry, Supreme Court No. 23-350, November 1, 2024

Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel v. Phillip D. Estep, Supreme Court No. 24-622, November 21, 2024

Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Donna E. Taylor, Supreme Court No. 23-133, December 16, 2024

Follow Us On

Office of Disciplinary Counsel

West Virginia Judicial Tower4700 MacCorkle Avenue SE, Suite 1200 Charleston, West Virginia 25304

Office: (304) 558-7999

Fax: (304) 558-4015


Hours of Operation:

9 AM - 5 PM | Monday - Friday

* Closed For All State Holidays *


Copyright 2024 - Thank you for visiting the Office of Disciplinary Counsel's website. The ODC strives to ensure the dissemination of timely, accurate public information. The information contained in this site is provided for your use and convenience. It is subject to change without notice. Although the information on the site is believed to be correct, its accuracy cannot be guaranteed. We will update our website annually, or more frequently to reflect rule changes and additions to the digest of lawyer discipline. The ODC disclaims liability for any error or omission.

The ODC does not favor any one group over another, nor does the use of any link to any organization's website herein constitute an endorsement of that organization. The ODC disclaims responsibility for the content of any site referenced from this website.

Website designed by StrongRapport strongrapport.com Developed by Uziel Matthew Tee disenyo.carrd.co